冒充的永春班 - Penang 区

jacky_sama

K-One (Farlim 区) 的健身房只有拳击/泰拳和其他类。我们已经收到投诉说那里的咏春拳是从YouTube学了然后再教导其他人，所以要小心要被受骗。你可以去其他学院得到正宗 / 有根据来源 / 专业的咏春拳课程, 而不是被不专业 / 不正宗的教练来教你学错的咏春拳, 简单来说是误导. 他们甚至说不出咏春拳来自何处，哪所学校，大师或血统的名称.  每一个后辈都会知道谁前辈的历史尤其是在武术界。咏春拳虽然是在一个小世界里的范围但是以足够可以了解或知道你我，但是这个学院是很肯定不是拥有正宗血统的咏春拳学校。

pizzaman

K- one gym in farlim only have kickboxing/muaythai and others class. we have received complain that there are fake wing chun class there, learn from youtube and teach, becareful from being conned .You can go for other classes there but not Wing Chun as they are not certified , has no Wing Chun background, cannot even tell where they come from, which school, name of the grandmaster or lineage, every son will know who is the father and mother especially in martial arts. Wing Chun is a small world where we know each other, but this one is certainly NOT under all lineage/schools of Wing Chun.

hoechinseng

哗，那这是摆明在骗钱啊！正真武林败类！

jacky_sama

所以大家要警惕

小傻蛋

哇～这次ringo大条了～

pizzaman

這個的不是Ringo，Ringo 是在 Prima tanjung ，這個是在 Farlim 的

magicity

“你可以去其他学院得到正宗 / 有根据来源 / 专业的咏春拳课程, 而不是被不专业 / 不正宗的教练来教你学错的咏春拳, 简单来说是误导. 他们甚至说不出咏春拳来自何处，哪所学校，大师或血统的名称.  每一个后辈都会知道谁前辈的历史尤其是在武术界。咏春拳虽然是在一个小世界里的范围但是以足够可以了解或知道你我，但是这个学院是很肯定不是拥有正宗血统的咏春拳学校”

你认为这些很重要吗？每个人练武的目的和宗旨都不同，何谓虚何谓实？何谓真何谓假？你那么肯定人家教的不是“真”咏春？而你教/练的就是“正统”的？你连名带姓把人家的武馆都写出来你的武品在那里？你证实了他们的是假的？如何假？不要为了一己之私而没黑别人，假如他们真的“没料”在他们那里学武的自然会过去你那边。
不过我可以告诉你，凡是在K1 FARLIM里练武之人都会被他们的师傅的练武精神，对MARTIAL ART的热诚，奉献和牺牲而敬佩不已。我就是其中一位学生，在人生理遇到了这么一位师傅，有幸之极。

pizzaman

if they are really came from  Wing Chun , then from which school and which lineage? its not about school, but why are you avoiding the question, and keep saying its not important on where your Wing Chun come from, if like that then can straight away learn from youtube la, no right or wrong also. we're not trying to say which school is better, but at least to show where you come from, if like that, every Tom, Dick and harry can start to teach wing chun and just say, oh, we can;t tell where we are from, because we are low profile

pizzaman

nobody stop your school from teaching other art, but teaching Wing Chun without formal way or actually learn before is misleading and its disturbing the Wing Chun community that's why we need to stand out. Most WIng Chun school can be trace by the Wing Chun organization/community no matter which school or lineage, if your school really is a Wing Chun school or class, we are happy that you guys teach, if not, then don't make a bad name for Wing Chun and what you guys are doing is wrong, don't manipulate the story and tell people you are good guys.

孔雀王子

一個真正的詠春拳師傅，是能夠把每一個手法包括小念頭，尋橋，標指還有木人樁全部很細緻化的講解給每一位學生/徒弟，然後當場示範這些手法的實戰性，樓主可以先看清楚這個師傅有沒有做到這點。。當然，樓主如果也學過詠春的話，可以去試試看他的黐手

pizzaman

回复 11# 孔雀王子
是的

unicorn2012

回复 8# magicity


    来源是非常的重要。。。。孩子一定要知道爸爸姓什么名什么。。。如果不知道的话那就你在自起自己的来源。。。。
一个真正的永春师傅不是由自己说的。。。师傅说你是我徒弟那才是贵重。。。

白千军

一段日子没进来，怎么多了那么多骗人和被骗的人

斗牛犬王

相关事件阿都拉已经向警方举报了

斗牛犬王

big2me 发表于 23-9-2012 04:21 PM
咏春没有十年功，怎么可以开班授课
看来叶问2 里 叶问要收徒弟需要通过洪金宝 那段也是需要的。

而且还是有德高望重的假师傅做贼喊贼

rtck21

等下他们叫你出来群殴就惨了.....

轻风静

如果是假,肯定真不了.... 日久见人心啊....